{"id":"0f4c305ca758e709e7aebd30c62f161b425562b3453c5839ecf4527c1615a93e","title":"Daniel Culbertson reports in Indeed Hiring Lab on a gradual labor-market cooldown","argument":"On January 31, 2024, Daniel Culbertson’s report for Indeed Hiring Lab describes a labor-market cooldown that reaches retail-related job postings unevenly. Overall postings remained above their pre-pandemic level, but had declined year over year; Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline. Retail and Food Preparation & Service postings also declined, while remaining above that baseline. Culbertson says wage growth in those two categories had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels, after easing from the highs of the pandemic recovery. The report draws on Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data for employment trends and Indeed postings and advertised wages for its other measures. Its picture is not of every category moving alike: Hospitality & Tourism stands out for its sharper decline and below-baseline postings. The report does not establish what these posting and wage trends mean for hiring, employment or workers’ pay in practice.","topicIds":["work-and-business--jobs-and-occupations","job-displacement-and-creation"],"domain":"other","claimType":"attributed reading","limits":"Text as retrieved on October 30, 2026; originally published January 31, 2024.","speaker":{"name":"Indeed Hiring Lab","roleAtSource":"Publisher"},"source":{"title":"US Q4 2023 Retail Labor Market Update: Hospitality & Tourism Jobs Declining More Quickly Amid Gradual Cooldown","publisher":"Indeed Hiring Lab","format":"Article","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","publishedAt":"2024-01-31","dateBasis":"Date from the publisher’s archive: its article address or archive listing."},"evidence":[{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says overall job postings remained above their pre-pandemic level while declining year over year.","excerpt":"The Indeed Job Postings Index (JPI) stood at 124 on Jan. 12, meaning total postings were still 24% above their level from Feb. 1, 2020. Postings were down 14.8% year-over-year","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline, unlike the other cited retail-related categories.","excerpt":"Postings for Hospitality & Tourism jobs, however, were down 22.6% over the past year as of Jan. 12, and are now 6% below their pre-pandemic baseline.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that advertised wage growth in Retail and Food Preparation & Service had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels.","excerpt":"year-over-year growth in advertised wages in the Retail and Food Preparation & Service categories in December 2023 clocked in at 3.4% and 3.6%, respectively, about even with their pre-pandemic levels.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says it uses Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data to track Retail employment trends.","excerpt":"The Indeed Hiring Lab tracks Retail employment trends, analyzing the latest Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Escape Meridian reads the report as showing an uneven cooldown: Hospitality & Tourism postings stand out both for their decline and for falling below their pre-pandemic baseline.","excerpt":"Most segments of the Retail sector are trending largely in line with the overall labor market slowdown — down over the year, but still comfortably above pre-pandemic levels — with one notable exception.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Escape Meridian interpretation"}],"sourceMedia":{"status":"unchecked","sourceUrl":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","checkedAt":null,"items":[]},"assumptions":[],"openQuestion":{"attribution":"Open question","text":"How did these posting and advertised-wage trends translate into actual hiring and workers’ pay?"},"whatWouldChangeView":{"attribution":"Change condition not recorded","text":""},"editorialComparisons":[],"live":{"title":"Daniel Culbertson reports in Indeed Hiring Lab on a gradual labor-market cooldown","summary":"On January 31, 2024, Daniel Culbertson’s report for Indeed Hiring Lab describes a labor-market cooldown that reaches retail-related job postings unevenly. Overall postings remained above their pre-pandemic level, but had declined year over year; Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline. Retail and Food Preparation & Service postings also declined, while remaining above that baseline. Culbertson says wage growth in those two categories had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels, after easing from the highs of the pandemic recovery. The report draws on Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data for employment trends and Indeed postings and advertised wages for its other measures. Its picture is not of every category moving alike: Hospitality & Tourism stands out for its sharper decline and below-baseline postings. The report does not establish what these posting and wage trends mean for hiring, employment or workers’ pay in practice.","question":"How did these posting and advertised-wage trends translate into actual hiring and workers’ pay?","claims":[{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says overall job postings remained above their pre-pandemic level while declining year over year.","excerpt":"The Indeed Job Postings Index (JPI) stood at 124 on Jan. 12, meaning total postings were still 24% above their level from Feb. 1, 2020. Postings were down 14.8% year-over-year","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline, unlike the other cited retail-related categories.","excerpt":"Postings for Hospitality & Tourism jobs, however, were down 22.6% over the past year as of Jan. 12, and are now 6% below their pre-pandemic baseline.","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that advertised wage growth in Retail and Food Preparation & Service had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels.","excerpt":"year-over-year growth in advertised wages in the Retail and Food Preparation & Service categories in December 2023 clocked in at 3.4% and 3.6%, respectively, about even with their pre-pandemic levels.","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says it uses Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data to track Retail employment trends.","excerpt":"The Indeed Hiring Lab tracks Retail employment trends, analyzing the latest Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data.","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Escape Meridian reads the report as showing an uneven cooldown: Hospitality & Tourism postings stand out both for their decline and for falling below their pre-pandemic baseline.","excerpt":"Most segments of the Retail sector are trending largely in line with the overall labor market slowdown — down over the year, but still comfortably above pre-pandemic levels — with one notable exception.","support":"interpretation"}],"limitations":["Text as retrieved on October 30, 2026; originally published January 31, 2024."],"mediaId":null,"correctionReason":null,"id":"0f4c305ca758e709e7aebd30c62f161b425562b3453c5839ecf4527c1615a93e","publicationId":"726b98d6-c243-5575-24d0-ba6750ec4038","version":1,"sourceUrl":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","sourceTitle":"US Q4 2023 Retail Labor Market Update: Hospitality & Tourism Jobs Declining More Quickly Amid Gradual Cooldown","publisher":"Indeed Hiring Lab","publishedAt":null,"originalPublished":{"value":"2024-01-31","precision":"day","basis":"backfill:publisher_archive_date"},"firstObservedAt":"2026-10-30T06:26:13.613Z","createdAt":"2026-11-21T18:08:10.254Z","historical":true,"entityIds":[],"topicIds":["work-and-business--jobs-and-occupations","job-displacement-and-creation"],"media":[],"sourceMedia":{"status":"unchecked","sourceUrl":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","checkedAt":null,"items":[]},"editorialDecision":{"outcome":"accept","mediaId":null,"inputHash":"6041976498e0130d9438ea7234c66bb2e300ba135beb0e8bdb7b2c450d7e358e","rubricVersion":"em-backfill-context/3","provider":"typesafe","model":"jev-1.13.0","reasonCodes":["bridge_admitted_by_model"],"confidence":1,"decidedAt":"2026-10-30T06:26:12.485Z"},"provenance":{"textHash":"91a15fec0bf690e051db9ca6be962a55f8f215568476cd7f2f329961398d24c2","observationId":"9a792ef7dda58d98227e787c54e1f37d7158870358650652d98ddcfa7db9fbd2","retrievedAt":"2026-10-30T06:27:45.225Z","kind":"publisher-page","preparer":{"model":"openai/gpt-6-luna","runId":"aacffba9-d69b-4850-5e1f-64b7922876c2"},"reviewer":{"model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5","runId":"778b39da-38dc-fc77-1dab-2e4241420cbf"}},"audit":{"status":"passed","reviewedAt":"2026-11-21T18:03:25.802Z","model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5"}},"canonicalUrl":"https://escapemeridian.com/readings/daniel-culbertson-reports-in-indeed-hiring-lab-on-a-gradual-0f4c305c","formats":{"html":"/readings/daniel-culbertson-reports-in-indeed-hiring-lab-on-a-gradual-0f4c305c","markdown":"/readings/daniel-culbertson-reports-in-indeed-hiring-lab-on-a-gradual-0f4c305c.md","json":"/readings/daniel-culbertson-reports-in-indeed-hiring-lab-on-a-gradual-0f4c305c.json"},"attribution":"Headline and summary by Escape Meridian, prepared by Luna from the attributed source. A source check is not independent confirmation of the source’s claims.","maintainedGuideLinks":[],"conditions":[],"readerContext":{"version":"reader-context-v1","attribution":"Reference context selected by Escape Meridian; separate from source evidence. Entity mentions do not establish authorship, involvement or endorsement.","terms":[],"entities":[{"id":"indeed-hiring-lab","name":"Indeed Hiring Lab","kind":"organization","context":"Indeed Hiring Lab is the economic research arm of the job site Indeed, publishing analyses of job postings, wages and hiring trends.","referenceUrls":["https://www.hiringlab.org/","https://www.hiringlab.org/feed/"],"path":"/entities/indeed-hiring-lab","json":"/entities/indeed-hiring-lab.json","markdown":"/entities/indeed-hiring-lab.md"},{"id":"us-bls","name":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","kind":"organization","context":"The Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes US data on employment, pay, prices and productivity.","referenceUrls":["https://www.bls.gov/"],"path":"/entities/us-bls","json":"/entities/us-bls.json","markdown":"/entities/us-bls.md"}]},"researchQuestions":[],"withdrawn":false,"references":{"schemaVersion":1,"target":{"type":"reading","id":"0f4c305ca758e709e7aebd30c62f161b425562b3453c5839ecf4527c1615a93e","revision":"726b98d6-c243-5575-24d0-ba6750ec4038","revisionKind":"publication-id","title":"Daniel Culbertson reports in Indeed Hiring Lab on a gradual labor-market cooldown","url":"https://escapemeridian.com/readings/daniel-culbertson-reports-in-indeed-hiring-lab-on-a-gradual-0f4c305c"},"source":{"type":"source","id":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","revision":"91a15fec0bf690e051db9ca6be962a55f8f215568476cd7f2f329961398d24c2","revisionKind":"sha256-source-text","title":"US Q4 2023 Retail Labor Market Update: Hospitality & Tourism Jobs Declining More Quickly Amid Gradual Cooldown","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/"},"status":"available","items":[],"next":null,"scope":"Explicit citations in public readings to this reading. Shared topics are not citations. Other record types need an explicit reference adapter."},"revisions":[{"id":"0f4c305ca758e709e7aebd30c62f161b425562b3453c5839ecf4527c1615a93e","title":"Daniel Culbertson reports in Indeed Hiring Lab on a gradual labor-market cooldown","argument":"On January 31, 2024, Daniel Culbertson’s report for Indeed Hiring Lab describes a labor-market cooldown that reaches retail-related job postings unevenly. Overall postings remained above their pre-pandemic level, but had declined year over year; Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline. Retail and Food Preparation & Service postings also declined, while remaining above that baseline. Culbertson says wage growth in those two categories had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels, after easing from the highs of the pandemic recovery. The report draws on Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data for employment trends and Indeed postings and advertised wages for its other measures. Its picture is not of every category moving alike: Hospitality & Tourism stands out for its sharper decline and below-baseline postings. The report does not establish what these posting and wage trends mean for hiring, employment or workers’ pay in practice.","topicIds":["work-and-business--jobs-and-occupations","job-displacement-and-creation"],"domain":"other","claimType":"attributed reading","limits":"Text as retrieved on October 30, 2026; originally published January 31, 2024.","speaker":{"name":"Indeed Hiring Lab","roleAtSource":"Publisher"},"source":{"title":"US Q4 2023 Retail Labor Market Update: Hospitality & Tourism Jobs Declining More Quickly Amid Gradual Cooldown","publisher":"Indeed Hiring Lab","format":"Article","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","publishedAt":"2024-01-31","dateBasis":"Date from the publisher’s archive: its article address or archive listing."},"evidence":[{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says overall job postings remained above their pre-pandemic level while declining year over year.","excerpt":"The Indeed Job Postings Index (JPI) stood at 124 on Jan. 12, meaning total postings were still 24% above their level from Feb. 1, 2020. Postings were down 14.8% year-over-year","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline, unlike the other cited retail-related categories.","excerpt":"Postings for Hospitality & Tourism jobs, however, were down 22.6% over the past year as of Jan. 12, and are now 6% below their pre-pandemic baseline.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that advertised wage growth in Retail and Food Preparation & Service had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels.","excerpt":"year-over-year growth in advertised wages in the Retail and Food Preparation & Service categories in December 2023 clocked in at 3.4% and 3.6%, respectively, about even with their pre-pandemic levels.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says it uses Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data to track Retail employment trends.","excerpt":"The Indeed Hiring Lab tracks Retail employment trends, analyzing the latest Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Source-stated"},{"text":"Escape Meridian reads the report as showing an uneven cooldown: Hospitality & Tourism postings stand out both for their decline and for falling below their pre-pandemic baseline.","excerpt":"Most segments of the Retail sector are trending largely in line with the overall labor market slowdown — down over the year, but still comfortably above pre-pandemic levels — with one notable exception.","url":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","relationship":"Escape Meridian interpretation"}],"sourceMedia":{"status":"unchecked","sourceUrl":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","checkedAt":null,"items":[]},"assumptions":[],"openQuestion":{"attribution":"Open question","text":"How did these posting and advertised-wage trends translate into actual hiring and workers’ pay?"},"whatWouldChangeView":{"attribution":"Change condition not recorded","text":""},"editorialComparisons":[],"live":{"title":"Daniel Culbertson reports in Indeed Hiring Lab on a gradual labor-market cooldown","summary":"On January 31, 2024, Daniel Culbertson’s report for Indeed Hiring Lab describes a labor-market cooldown that reaches retail-related job postings unevenly. Overall postings remained above their pre-pandemic level, but had declined year over year; Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline. Retail and Food Preparation & Service postings also declined, while remaining above that baseline. Culbertson says wage growth in those two categories had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels, after easing from the highs of the pandemic recovery. The report draws on Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data for employment trends and Indeed postings and advertised wages for its other measures. Its picture is not of every category moving alike: Hospitality & Tourism stands out for its sharper decline and below-baseline postings. The report does not establish what these posting and wage trends mean for hiring, employment or workers’ pay in practice.","question":"How did these posting and advertised-wage trends translate into actual hiring and workers’ pay?","claims":[{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says overall job postings remained above their pre-pandemic level while declining year over year.","excerpt":"The Indeed Job Postings Index (JPI) stood at 124 on Jan. 12, meaning total postings were still 24% above their level from Feb. 1, 2020. Postings were down 14.8% year-over-year","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that Hospitality & Tourism postings had fallen below their pre-pandemic baseline, unlike the other cited retail-related categories.","excerpt":"Postings for Hospitality & Tourism jobs, however, were down 22.6% over the past year as of Jan. 12, and are now 6% below their pre-pandemic baseline.","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab reports that advertised wage growth in Retail and Food Preparation & Service had slowed to about their pre-pandemic levels.","excerpt":"year-over-year growth in advertised wages in the Retail and Food Preparation & Service categories in December 2023 clocked in at 3.4% and 3.6%, respectively, about even with their pre-pandemic levels.","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Indeed Hiring Lab says it uses Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data to track Retail employment trends.","excerpt":"The Indeed Hiring Lab tracks Retail employment trends, analyzing the latest Indeed and Bureau of Labor Statistics data.","support":"source-stated"},{"text":"Escape Meridian reads the report as showing an uneven cooldown: Hospitality & Tourism postings stand out both for their decline and for falling below their pre-pandemic baseline.","excerpt":"Most segments of the Retail sector are trending largely in line with the overall labor market slowdown — down over the year, but still comfortably above pre-pandemic levels — with one notable exception.","support":"interpretation"}],"limitations":["Text as retrieved on October 30, 2026; originally published January 31, 2024."],"mediaId":null,"correctionReason":null,"id":"0f4c305ca758e709e7aebd30c62f161b425562b3453c5839ecf4527c1615a93e","publicationId":"726b98d6-c243-5575-24d0-ba6750ec4038","version":1,"sourceUrl":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","sourceTitle":"US Q4 2023 Retail Labor Market Update: Hospitality & Tourism Jobs Declining More Quickly Amid Gradual Cooldown","publisher":"Indeed Hiring Lab","publishedAt":null,"originalPublished":{"value":"2024-01-31","precision":"day","basis":"backfill:publisher_archive_date"},"firstObservedAt":"2026-10-30T06:26:13.613Z","createdAt":"2026-11-21T18:08:10.254Z","historical":true,"entityIds":[],"topicIds":["work-and-business--jobs-and-occupations","job-displacement-and-creation"],"media":[],"sourceMedia":{"status":"unchecked","sourceUrl":"https://hiringlab.indeed.com/2024/01/31/q4-retail-labor-market-update/","checkedAt":null,"items":[]},"editorialDecision":{"outcome":"accept","mediaId":null,"inputHash":"6041976498e0130d9438ea7234c66bb2e300ba135beb0e8bdb7b2c450d7e358e","rubricVersion":"em-backfill-context/3","provider":"typesafe","model":"jev-1.13.0","reasonCodes":["bridge_admitted_by_model"],"confidence":1,"decidedAt":"2026-10-30T06:26:12.485Z"},"provenance":{"textHash":"91a15fec0bf690e051db9ca6be962a55f8f215568476cd7f2f329961398d24c2","observationId":"9a792ef7dda58d98227e787c54e1f37d7158870358650652d98ddcfa7db9fbd2","retrievedAt":"2026-10-30T06:27:45.225Z","kind":"publisher-page","preparer":{"model":"openai/gpt-6-luna","runId":"aacffba9-d69b-4850-5e1f-64b7922876c2"},"reviewer":{"model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5","runId":"778b39da-38dc-fc77-1dab-2e4241420cbf"}},"audit":{"status":"passed","reviewedAt":"2026-11-21T18:03:25.802Z","model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5"}}}],"audits":[{"publicationId":"726b98d6-c243-5575-24d0-ba6750ec4038","verdict":"passed","findings":[{"dimension":"attribution","status":"pass","explanation":"This is a single report by Daniel Culbertson for Indeed Hiring Lab, not a listing; the carousel titles at the end are related links. The reading attributes the findings to Culbertson and Indeed Hiring Lab throughout and labels its own reading as Escape Meridian interpretation.","excerpt":"By Daniel Culbertson\nJanuary 31, 2024"},{"dimension":"summary","status":"pass","explanation":"The title, summary and question match the report. It describes an overall cooling, Hospitality & Tourism as the exception below baseline, and advertised wage growth back near pre-pandemic levels. Terms like pre-pandemic baseline and job postings are understandable to a general reader. The summary acknowledges that postings and advertised wages are not actual hiring or pay. The question follows from that gap.","excerpt":"Most segments of the Retail sector are trending largely in line with the overall labor market slowdown"},{"dimension":"date","status":"pass","explanation":"January 31, 2024 matches the dateline and originalPublished at day precision. Nothing later is presented as known. The page was modified on 2024-04-02, but the dates and data the reading uses (Jan. 12 figures, December 2023 wages) are plainly part of the original report. The later carousel links are not used. The evidence is a publisher page, so no archive disclosure is required.","excerpt":"January 31, 2024"},{"dimension":"support","status":"pass","explanation":"Each claim is directly supported by the quoted passages from the body of the original report, not by any likely later edit. The interpretation is labeled and grounded in the source's 'one notable exception' framing. The summary claims no benefits or costs beyond the evidence, and it states what remains unknown.","excerpt":"Postings for Hospitality & Tourism jobs, however, were down 22.6% over the past year as of Jan. 12, and are now 6% below their pre-pandemic baseline."},{"dimension":"media","status":"pass","explanation":"No media was selected and no verified media candidates were supplied, so there is no identity or relevance issue.","excerpt":null}],"createdAt":"2026-11-21T18:03:25.802Z","model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5"}],"correctionUrl":"https://escapemeridian.com/corrections/"}