Feng, Dana, Yun, Bhada, Wang, April Yi · Jan 31, 2026
arXiv: From Junior to Senior on Agency in AI-Mediated Software Engineering
Markdown · JSON · Original source
Authors Dana Feng, Bhada Yun and April Yi Wang argue that AI is changing not only how software engineers code, but who holds agency across work and professional growth. Their three-phase mixed-methods study gathered senior developers’ accounts, observed juniors in an AI-assisted debugging task, and had seniors review junior prompt histories. The authors report that organizational policies constrain agency more than individual preferences. They say experienced developers retain control through detailed delegation, while novices can struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance. They argue that seniors’ pre-AI foundational instincts can help them steer modern tools and mentor juniors early in AI-encouraged careers. The paper’s concern is not simply whether engineers use AI, but whether they can direct their work and continue learning as AI becomes more autonomous. The authors suggest three practices focused on preserving agency in coding, learning and mentorship; the abstract does not describe those practices in detail. Their findings offer a perspective on how workplace rules and experience may shape AI-mediated software engineering, but the abstract does not establish how broadly the findings apply.
Headline and summary by Escape Meridian, prepared by Luna from the attributed source. A source check is not independent confirmation of the source’s claims.
Original source
· Article
Source details
Original source date: Jan 31, 2026 (2026-01-31).
Date basis: Date basis not provided.
Added to Escape Meridian: 2026-11-20T13:52:03.002Z. First observed: 2026-11-20T13:50:23.739Z. Retrieved: 2026-11-20T13:51:12.531Z.
Referenced by
Recorded citations in public readings. A reference alone does not establish agreement or influence.
No public references recorded here yet.
Limits
The abstract describes small participant groups: 5 seniors in the Delphi process, 10 juniors in the debugging task, and 5 additional seniors reviewing prompt histories. The abstract does not describe the three suggested practices in detail. The evidence here is the publisher-page abstract, so the reported findings and scope cannot be assessed against the full paper from this excerpt alone.
Open question
What are the three practices the authors suggest for preserving agency in coding, learning and mentorship?
Source-stated
The authors frame agentic AI as changing who holds agency across software engineering work and professional growth, not only coding methods.
AI is not just changing how engineers code-it is reshaping who holds agency across work and professional growth.
Source-stated
The study combined senior accounts, an AI-assisted debugging task with juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by seniors.
ACTA combined with a Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors.
Source-stated
The authors report that organizational policies constrain agency more than individual preferences, while experienced developers use detailed delegation to retain control.
agency in software engineering is primarily constrained by organizational policies rather than individual preferences, with experienced developers maintaining control through detailed delegation
Source-stated
The authors report that novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance, and identify senior developers’ foundational instincts as valuable for steering tools and mentoring juniors.
novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance. Seniors leverage pre-AI foundational instincts to steer modern tools and possess valuable perspectives for mentoring juniors
Source-stated
The authors suggest three practices focused on preserving agency in coding, learning and mentorship as AI grows more autonomous.
we suggest three practices that focus on preserving agency in software engineering for coding, learning, and mentorship, especially as AI grows increasingly autonomous.
Source and contributor context
Feng, Dana, Yun, Bhada, Wang, April Yi · Article author
These are credits stated by the source; they do not establish a profile match or authorship of every passage.
Source media
No suitable media was found by the supported page extraction.
Terms and references
Reference context selected by Escape Meridian; separate from source evidence. Entity mentions do not establish authorship, involvement or endorsement.
Agentic AI
AI systems that plan and carry out a series of steps toward a goal, often by using other software, rather than giving one answer.
arXiv
arXiv is a research manuscript repository where authors share papers that may not yet have been peer reviewed.
Editorial provenance
Version 1. Publication ID: 67e307de-5222-4c91-8415-105765030ad0.
Prepared by gpt-6-luna; grounding review by gpt-6-luna.
Source check: passed by anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 on 2026-11-20T13:52:03.002Z. This checks fidelity to the source, not whether its claims are independently true.
Editorial selection: accept; reasons: useful_perspective.
Observation: 30d27a57fa84534164538408aecf4002de02f5ab4e5de3119737ecd8e942c4ac. Source text hash: adc33f720095a6f95414cb7e28d8e544945fe7005629f4f90dee1b88d93e8edf.
Where this evidence matters
- AI becomes an apprenticeship multiplier · direct · context
Feng, Yun and Wang's CHI '26 paper (arXiv v1 31 Jan 2026, v2 11 Feb 2026; observed here 20 Nov 2026) is a small mixed-methods study of junior and senior software engineers using agentic AI. It combines an ACTA and Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors. Only the abstract is available. It does not measure hiring, pay, entry openings or progression, so it does not reach the entry-pressure paths, the hiring triggers or the main hiring forecast. Retrieval came from the token 'mentoring'. The arXiv tool listings are page furniture. The match is substantive for the guide's learning conditions in an exposed digital occupation. The authors report that 'novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance'. That bears directly on entry-opportunities-renew condition 1 (workers can question the tool, receive feedback and build expertise beyond accepting its output) and careers-apprenticeship condition 1 (progression depends on detecting and correcting AI mistakes). It shows these conditions are not met by default; they have to be built. The authors also report that seniors 'possess valuable perspectives for mentoring juniors'. That is consistent with careers-apprenticeship condition 0, which treats mentoring as a lever, though the study does not test whether mentoring changes outcomes. Their finding that agency is 'primarily constrained by organizational policies rather than individual preferences' bears on entry-opportunities-renew condition 0. It places the decision with the employer, as the guide does, rather than with individual workers. This is context, not support or challenge. Over-reliance is an observed behaviour in one debugging task, not evidence that people are rewarded for output over understanding (careers-hollow-learning condition 1). It is also not evidence that progression falls. The finding extends Mollick's classroom-based argument, that how AI is used determines whether people learn, to junior software engineers. That connection is EM's. The sample is very small, the abstract does not say whether the juniors were employed, and the three proposed practices are the authors' suggestions, not tested interventions.
Read the revision from 2026-11-20 - AI becomes an apprenticeship multiplier · direct · context
Feng, Yun and Wang's CHI '26 paper (arXiv v1 31 Jan 2026, v2 11 Feb 2026; observed here 20 Nov 2026) is a small mixed-methods study of junior and senior software engineers using agentic AI. It combines an ACTA and Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors. Only the abstract is available. It does not measure hiring, pay, entry openings or progression, so it does not reach the entry-pressure paths, the hiring triggers or the main hiring forecast. Retrieval came from the token 'mentoring'. The arXiv tool listings are page furniture. The match is substantive for the guide's learning conditions in an exposed digital occupation. The authors report that 'novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance'. That bears directly on entry-opportunities-renew condition 1 (workers can question the tool, receive feedback and build expertise beyond accepting its output) and careers-apprenticeship condition 1 (progression depends on detecting and correcting AI mistakes). It shows these conditions are not met by default; they have to be built. The authors also report that seniors 'possess valuable perspectives for mentoring juniors'. That is consistent with careers-apprenticeship condition 0, which treats mentoring as a lever, though the study does not test whether mentoring changes outcomes. Their finding that agency is 'primarily constrained by organizational policies rather than individual preferences' bears on entry-opportunities-renew condition 0. It places the decision with the employer, as the guide does, rather than with individual workers. This is context, not support or challenge. Over-reliance is an observed behaviour in one debugging task, not evidence that people are rewarded for output over understanding (careers-hollow-learning condition 1). It is also not evidence that progression falls. The finding extends Mollick's classroom-based argument, that how AI is used determines whether people learn, to junior software engineers. That connection is EM's. The sample is very small, the abstract does not say whether the juniors were employed, and the three proposed practices are the authors' suggestions, not tested interventions.
Read the revision from 2026-11-20 - AI becomes part of a stronger apprenticeship · direct · context
Feng, Yun and Wang's CHI '26 paper (arXiv v1 31 Jan 2026, v2 11 Feb 2026; observed here 20 Nov 2026) is a small mixed-methods study of junior and senior software engineers using agentic AI. It combines an ACTA and Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors. Only the abstract is available. It does not measure hiring, pay, entry openings or progression, so it does not reach the entry-pressure paths, the hiring triggers or the main hiring forecast. Retrieval came from the token 'mentoring'. The arXiv tool listings are page furniture. The match is substantive for the guide's learning conditions in an exposed digital occupation. The authors report that 'novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance'. That bears directly on entry-opportunities-renew condition 1 (workers can question the tool, receive feedback and build expertise beyond accepting its output) and careers-apprenticeship condition 1 (progression depends on detecting and correcting AI mistakes). It shows these conditions are not met by default; they have to be built. The authors also report that seniors 'possess valuable perspectives for mentoring juniors'. That is consistent with careers-apprenticeship condition 0, which treats mentoring as a lever, though the study does not test whether mentoring changes outcomes. Their finding that agency is 'primarily constrained by organizational policies rather than individual preferences' bears on entry-opportunities-renew condition 0. It places the decision with the employer, as the guide does, rather than with individual workers. This is context, not support or challenge. Over-reliance is an observed behaviour in one debugging task, not evidence that people are rewarded for output over understanding (careers-hollow-learning condition 1). It is also not evidence that progression falls. The finding extends Mollick's classroom-based argument, that how AI is used determines whether people learn, to junior software engineers. That connection is EM's. The sample is very small, the abstract does not say whether the juniors were employed, and the three proposed practices are the authors' suggestions, not tested interventions.
Read the revision from 2026-11-20 - AI becomes part of a stronger apprenticeship · direct · context
Feng, Yun and Wang's CHI '26 paper (arXiv v1 31 Jan 2026, v2 11 Feb 2026; observed here 20 Nov 2026) is a small mixed-methods study of junior and senior software engineers using agentic AI. It combines an ACTA and Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors. Only the abstract is available. It does not measure hiring, pay, entry openings or progression, so it does not reach the entry-pressure paths, the hiring triggers or the main hiring forecast. Retrieval came from the token 'mentoring'. The arXiv tool listings are page furniture. The match is substantive for the guide's learning conditions in an exposed digital occupation. The authors report that 'novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance'. That bears directly on entry-opportunities-renew condition 1 (workers can question the tool, receive feedback and build expertise beyond accepting its output) and careers-apprenticeship condition 1 (progression depends on detecting and correcting AI mistakes). It shows these conditions are not met by default; they have to be built. The authors also report that seniors 'possess valuable perspectives for mentoring juniors'. That is consistent with careers-apprenticeship condition 0, which treats mentoring as a lever, though the study does not test whether mentoring changes outcomes. Their finding that agency is 'primarily constrained by organizational policies rather than individual preferences' bears on entry-opportunities-renew condition 0. It places the decision with the employer, as the guide does, rather than with individual workers. This is context, not support or challenge. Over-reliance is an observed behaviour in one debugging task, not evidence that people are rewarded for output over understanding (careers-hollow-learning condition 1). It is also not evidence that progression falls. The finding extends Mollick's classroom-based argument, that how AI is used determines whether people learn, to junior software engineers. That connection is EM's. The sample is very small, the abstract does not say whether the juniors were employed, and the three proposed practices are the authors' suggestions, not tested interventions.
Read the revision from 2026-11-20
Revision and source-check history
Version 1 · 2026-11-20T13:52:03.002Z
arXiv: From Junior to Senior on Agency in AI-Mediated Software Engineering
Authors Dana Feng, Bhada Yun and April Yi Wang argue that AI is changing not only how software engineers code, but who holds agency across work and professional growth. Their three-phase mixed-methods study gathered senior developers’ accounts, observed juniors in an AI-assisted debugging task, and had seniors review junior prompt histories. The authors report that organizational policies constrain agency more than individual preferences. They say experienced developers retain control through detailed delegation, while novices can struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance. They argue that seniors’ pre-AI foundational instincts can help them steer modern tools and mentor juniors early in AI-encouraged careers. The paper’s concern is not simply whether engineers use AI, but whether they can direct their work and continue learning as AI becomes more autonomous. The authors suggest three practices focused on preserving agency in coding, learning and mentorship; the abstract does not describe those practices in detail. Their findings offer a perspective on how workplace rules and experience may shape AI-mediated software engineering, but the abstract does not establish how broadly the findings apply.
Original source
· Article
Source details
Original source date: Jan 31, 2026 (2026-01-31).
Date basis: Date basis not provided.
Added to Escape Meridian: 2026-11-20T13:52:03.002Z. First observed: 2026-11-20T13:50:23.739Z. Retrieved: 2026-11-20T13:51:12.531Z.
Limits
The abstract describes small participant groups: 5 seniors in the Delphi process, 10 juniors in the debugging task, and 5 additional seniors reviewing prompt histories. The abstract does not describe the three suggested practices in detail. The evidence here is the publisher-page abstract, so the reported findings and scope cannot be assessed against the full paper from this excerpt alone.
Open question
What are the three practices the authors suggest for preserving agency in coding, learning and mentorship?
Source-stated
The authors frame agentic AI as changing who holds agency across software engineering work and professional growth, not only coding methods.
AI is not just changing how engineers code-it is reshaping who holds agency across work and professional growth.
Source-stated
The study combined senior accounts, an AI-assisted debugging task with juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by seniors.
ACTA combined with a Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors.
Source-stated
The authors report that organizational policies constrain agency more than individual preferences, while experienced developers use detailed delegation to retain control.
agency in software engineering is primarily constrained by organizational policies rather than individual preferences, with experienced developers maintaining control through detailed delegation
Source-stated
The authors report that novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance, and identify senior developers’ foundational instincts as valuable for steering tools and mentoring juniors.
novices struggle between over-reliance and cautious avoidance. Seniors leverage pre-AI foundational instincts to steer modern tools and possess valuable perspectives for mentoring juniors
Source-stated
The authors suggest three practices focused on preserving agency in coding, learning and mentorship as AI grows more autonomous.
we suggest three practices that focus on preserving agency in software engineering for coding, learning, and mentorship, especially as AI grows increasingly autonomous.
Source and contributor context
Feng, Dana, Yun, Bhada, Wang, April Yi · Article author
These are credits stated by the source; they do not establish a profile match or authorship of every passage.
Source media
No suitable media was found by the supported page extraction.
Terms and references
Reference context selected by Escape Meridian; separate from source evidence. Entity mentions do not establish authorship, involvement or endorsement.
Agentic AI
AI systems that plan and carry out a series of steps toward a goal, often by using other software, rather than giving one answer.
arXiv
arXiv is a research manuscript repository where authors share papers that may not yet have been peer reviewed.
Editorial provenance
Version 1. Publication ID: 67e307de-5222-4c91-8415-105765030ad0.
Prepared by gpt-6-luna; grounding review by gpt-6-luna.
Source check: passed by anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 on 2026-11-20T13:52:03.002Z. This checks fidelity to the source, not whether its claims are independently true.
Editorial selection: accept; reasons: useful_perspective.
Observation: 30d27a57fa84534164538408aecf4002de02f5ab4e5de3119737ecd8e942c4ac. Source text hash: adc33f720095a6f95414cb7e28d8e544945fe7005629f4f90dee1b88d93e8edf.
passed · 2026-11-20T13:52:03.002Z · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5
Publication: 67e307de-5222-4c91-8415-105765030ad0
attribution — pass: The reading names the arXiv authors Dana Feng, Bhada Yun and April Yi Wang correctly. It keeps the findings attributed with phrasing such as 'the authors report' and 'they argue', so the abstract's claims are not presented as established fact.
Authors:Dana Feng, Bhada Yun, April Yi Wang
summary — pass: The reading leads with the authors' central thesis and describes the three study phases in plain language, avoiding unexplained ACTA and Delphi jargon. It preserves the policy-over-preference finding, the senior/novice contrast and the mentorship argument. Minor point: 'novices can struggle' slightly softens the source's 'novices struggle'. The smallest repair would be 'novices struggle'. This is not material. 'Agentic AI' can be handled by a term tooltip. The question names a real gap the abstract leaves open.
AI is not just changing how engineers code-it is reshaping who holds agency across work and professional growth.
date — pass: originalPublished is 2026-01-31, which matches the v1 submission date. The v2 revision on 11 Feb 2026 is correctly not used.
Submitted on 31 Jan 2026 (v1), last revised 11 Feb 2026 (this version, v2)
support — pass: Each claim matches its verbatim abstract excerpt. The reading adds no invented benefits or costs. Its limitations accurately note the small samples (5, 10 and 5 participants), that the three practices are not detailed, and that the evidence is only the abstract. The closing caution about generalizability is appropriately hedged.
ACTA combined with a Delphi process with 5 seniors, an AI-assisted debugging task with 10 juniors, and blind reviews of junior prompt histories by 5 more seniors.
media — pass: The selected media is the verified direct link to the original arXiv abstract page, which matches the source URL. It is the most direct way to reach the paper.
Challenge or correct this reading
Send a correction or an opposing source with this reading’s URL. Disagreement and uncertainty can remain unresolved.
AI systems that plan and carry out a series of steps toward a goal, often by using other software, rather than giving one answer.
Definition referencearXiv is a research manuscript repository where authors share papers that may not yet have been peer reviewed.
Explore arXivAI systems that plan and carry out a series of steps toward a goal, often by using other software, rather than giving one answer.
Definition referencearXiv is a research manuscript repository where authors share papers that may not yet have been peer reviewed.
Explore arXiv